Ill-Gotten Gaines is:

Ned Gaines: Harmonica

Matt O'Toole: Drums, Percussion, Bass Guitar, Electric Guitar, Mandolin, Vocals

Nathan Soccorsy: Slide Guitar, Organ, Keyboards, Acoustic Guitar, Electric Guitar

Jon Guerrero (Left): Bass Guitar

Andy Gaines (Right): Acoustic Guitar, Electric Guitar, Vocals

Additional members:

Sean Wheatley: Stand-Up Bass

Lou Alexander: Fiddle